National
Campaign for Reforms in Governance
|
|
|
Governance
is characterised by the principles of participation,
where all men and women have a voice in decision-making;
rule of law, where all are equal before law and the
legal system is fair; transparency of policy making
institutions by ensuring information at the public domain;
responsiveness of institutions and processes in serving
all; equity in provision of equal opportunities to men
and women; accountability of the public and private
institutions to the citizens; effectiveness and efficiency
in optimum use of resources; consensus in mediating
the different needs to reach the best interests of all
groups; and with a long-term vision on human development |
|
| |
The Indian democracy has firmly established
its roots with a strong presence of 713 million voters. Institutions
that ensure a citizen’s franchise in a democracy, viz.,
the Parliament, State Assemblies, Courts, National and State
Election Commissions, and local institutions of governance
have long been established and are functional. Democratic
governance, however, largely depends on the degree to which
these institutions deliver on their promises of civil, cultural,
economic, political and social rights of citizens. |
| |
There is no doubt that we are lagging
behind in ensuring basic amenities of life and dignity of
life to millions of our fellow citizens. State’s capacities,
its responsiveness and accountability are being questioned.
Democratic governance in our country has proved to be meaningless
to most of the marginalised and poor. Even the Government
of India has expressed its concern on governance reform. The
Hon'ble President of India Shrimati Pratibha Devisingh Patil
in her speech in the Parliament said, “the major
focus of the Government would be reform of governance for
effective delivery of public services. Reports of the Administrative
Reforms Commission would guide the effort. Reform of structures
in the higher echelons of government, increased decentralisation,
inclusion of women and youth in governance, process reform
and public accountability would be key areas for focused action”. |
| |
Reforms in governance demand a participatory
and citizen-centric process---the way citizens, leaders and
public institutions interact with each other to make changes
happen. Civil society has two important roles to perform in
this process: 1) to be a proactive supporter of the reform
process and 2) to act as a watchdog and critic of the reform
process. This requires a larger role by the civil society
in enabling citizens and their institutions in engaging with
the reform processes. It has to interface with actors in governments
to make reforms in governance more transparent, accountable
and effective for the welfare of citizens. |
| |
Civil society organisations have been
proactively voicing the need for reforms in governance like
election reforms, judicial and police reforms, administrative
reforms and human rights issues (food, health, forest and
livelihood security, etc.) for many years. A few of them are
engaged in bringing about institutional reforms in local democratic
bodies (Panchayats and Municipal bodies) with mobilisation
and building accountability of Gram and Ward/Mohalla Sabhas.
Extensive work has also been undertaken by some on policy
issues related to participatory comprehensive district and
urban planning, capacity building of leaders, strengthening
of District Planning Committees, State Finance Commissions,
State Election Commissions, financial and administrative capacity
building of the local democratic bodies, women’s political
empowerment and leadership, pre-election voter awareness campaign
and strengthening of SC/ST leadership |
|
According to the Economic Survey 2008--09,
the share of Central Government expenditure on social services
including rural development in total expenditure (plan and
non-plan) has increased from 11.23 per cent in 2002--03 to
19.44 per cent in 2008--09 (RE) and the total social service
expenditure (central and states combined) has increased to
Rs 796,384 crore in 2003--04 to Rs 14, 85,536 crore (BE) in
2008*. A few progressive acts to secure the
rights of citizens have also been implemented like the Forest
Rights Act, Right to Information Act, National Rural Employment
Guarantee Act, Domestic Violence Act, Right to Education,
and others. Ironically, India has only slipped further down
to 128 from 127 on the Human Development Index as per the
2008 data.¨ This is primarily because the government has
not been bringing about the desired reforms in public institutions.
|
| |
Therefore, in the present context there
is an urgent need for reorganisation of effective reforms
in the functioning of public institutions and programmes with
respect to transparency and accountability in the public institutions.
Furthermore, there is an emerging consensus in India and other
countries to strengthen the decentralisation of political
and administrative authority in local governments. This has
been reflected in the Second Administrative Reform Commission
report and the Planning Commission’s initiatives on
district and inclusive planning |
| |
The principles and values that need to
be aggressively promoted to ensure effective, participatory
and people-centric governance are: |
| |
| •Inclusion-
Institutional frameworks must provide enabling spaces for citizens
to influence decision-making process of public institutions
for better service delivery and common public good. Citizens
should also be enabled to proactively participate in the election
process. |
| |
| •Devolution-
The principles of subsidiarity should be the basis of devolution
of the 3Fs (functions, functionaries, funds) to local governments.
Demands for devolution should come from citizens and their elected
representatives rather than the civil society, as is currently
the case. |
| |
| •Capacity-
Public education must precede and succeed policy reforms. The
level of awareness about the various progressive initiatives
in our country should increase among the citizens. Capacities
of new leadership among the youth, women, SCs and STs should
also be developed so that they can play effective roles in improving
the quality of life of their people. |
| |
•Dignity-
An effective mechanism needs to be put in place to ensure
the basic human rights and dignity of life of citizens. Although
legally banned, the practice of untouchability in a few social
realms, as reported in the media regularly, is a national
shame. The Tribal are being pushed to the peripheries of human
existence. Women are still not treated with respect. There
is a general fear among citizens in approaching the police
and other state organs, the very institutions that are supposed
to be our protectors. Despite constitutional provisions, the
right to land, food, forest and livelihood, the freedom of
expression, right to form associations to voice our civic
demands are regularly being encroached upon and snatched away. |
| |
The abovementioned issues require a consistent
alliance of energies, capacities and networks of various actors
at different levels, but on a common platform and sustainable
basis. The larger civil society (Community Based Organisations,
NGOs, media, academia and market) has to come together to
interface with the Government, public and private institutions
on mutually identified issues on governance reforms. |
| |
Realising the importance of reforms in
the existing institutions of governance, the campaign aims
to partner with a variety of institutions to bring together
synergies in isolated initiatives intended for governance
reform on a common platform. The objective is to facilitate
a coalition of campaigns and campaigners on different issues
(land rights, elections, food and health security) to have
an impact on the whole system of delivery. It is expected
that with the necessary impetus from the CSOs, much desirable
change will come about in the public institutions to make
them act in a responsible, responsive, transparent and accountable
manner. |
| |
| Campaign Approach |
| |
The campaign will build and facilitate
a national alliance of civil society organisations, media
and other actors at the state and national levels on reforms
in governance. The three main issues identified for reforms
in governance are as follows |
| (i) Political/Election reforms1 |
| (ii) Institutional reforms2 for democratic governance |
| (iii) Strengthening leadership3 |
| |
The abovementioned issues are broad in
nature and others can also be identified and prioritised on
the basis of the need of the state and networks/actors at
various levels. To initiate the campaign, the local government
election provides an opportunity to create an alliance of
interested CSOs, media, academia, networks and political parties.
The alliance would be a coalition of different organisations/individuals,
academia, think tanks and media, which would have a stake
(and say) in the mutually agreed initiatives in contributing
to the process in their capabilities through collective efforts.
It will be ensured that all members have an equal say in sustaining
the alliance. The campaign may initially focus on election
reforms in the states of Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Madhya
Pradesh and Haryana, where the election process of local bodies
has either been initiated or is in the process. Issues related
to devolution to local bodies for better service delivery,
free and transparent election procedures and able and dynamic
leadership will also be highlighted in the local government
elections. Simultaneously, the campaign would initiate an
alliance with other networks/actors working on the issues
of reforms in governance in other states like electoral reforms,
judicial reforms, police reforms, human rights and administrative
and fiscal reforms, etc. The focus of the intervention will
be based on the mutually agreed issues in these states. This
campaign will provide a common platform to jointly raise voices
for issues and concerns affecting reforms in governance. |
| |
The campaign will also forge partnerships
with a variety of civil society organisations like universities,
academic institutions, Bar Associations, Medical Associations,
Industry Association, Journalists’ Associations, Culture
and Art Association, Election Watch, etc.. Mainstream media
would also be a key stakeholder for citizen education and
public advocacy through the production of IEC and other communication
activities. Interface and dialogues will be organised with
constitutional/public institutions like the State Election
Commission, State Finance Commission, Central Finance Commission,
Election Commission of India, ministries, SC/ST Commissions,
Women Commissions, issue-specific cells of political parties
and others to seek their support, guidance and interventions
in addressing the identified issues of reforms in governance. |
|
| *27.5% of Indians live below the poverty line |
| *39% of the population is still illiterate. |
| *82% of rural Indians do not have sanitation facilities |
| *14% of the population does not have access to safe drinking
water. |
| *Not even a single doctor is available in 5000 Primary Health
Centres |
| *21% of rural population lives without a service of any doctor |
| *43 % children below the age of five are underweight |
| *61% deliveries are still un-institutional |
| *2.7% children of 7-10 years of age not-in school, and |
| *6.3% children of 11-14 years of age not in-school |
| |
| 1Political reforms would
include 1) Strengthening democracy through free and fair local,
state and national electoral processes; 2) Restoring the voters’
confidence in the political process and increase their participation;
3) Deepening democracy through public accountability and transparency,
to reduce the vested influence in elections. |
| |
| 2Entails transparent and accountable systems and
processes of decision-making in public institutions; it includes
both mobilisation and use of public resources for common public
good; it specially implies making government agencies and officials
responsive and accountable to citizens, in making policies,
designing programmes and implementing development projects;
ensuring devolution in local governments for better service
delivery. |
| |
| 3Ensuring access to information
to citizen and building their capacities to monitor the public
institutions’ functions, to participate in decision-making
and actively contribute to the public good. Marginalised sections
of citizens (SC, ST and women) should be empowered to participate
in decision-making processes and gaining political leadership.
|
| |